Team Overview for team COMP University of Pyongyang A (Composite Teams)

Speakers: Ioan Nascu and Owen Yeo

Round 1

Motion: THW officially recognise Scientology as a religion

Venue: Modern Languages Room (Old College)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 1After Round 1After Round 4
Opening GovernmentCARD C (Cardiff University)Third11st (0 points, 0 speaks)18th (1 points, 147 speaks)18th (5 points, 580 speaks)
Opening OppositionCOMP University of Pyongyang A (Composite Teams)Second21st (0 points, 0 speaks)9th (2 points, 156 speaks)21st (4 points, 597 speaks)
Closing GovernmentSWING Clare + Ethan (Swing Teams)Fourth01st (0 points, 0 speaks)24th (0 points, 145 speaks)16th (6 points, 573 speaks)
Closing OppositionULU Eleanor's Oppressed Penguins (University of London Union)First31st (0 points, 0 speaks)2nd (3 points, 160 speaks)5th (8 points, 622 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Catrin WilliamsCARD C73
ClareSWING Clare + Ethan72
EthanSWING Clare + Ethan73
Hassan Bin ShaheenULU Eleanor's Oppressed Penguins79
Ioan NascuCOMP University of Pyongyang A79
Jake SmithCARD C74
John TsopanisULU Eleanor's Oppressed Penguins81
Owen YeoCOMP University of Pyongyang A77

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairEd MiddletonUnaffiliated (N/A)
PanelistIgnacio Zinser StainesUnaffiliated (N/A)
PanelistKarolien MichielsUnaffiliated (N/A)
PanelistLouise DoughtyUnaffiliated (N/A)

Round 2

Motion: TH regrets the popularisation and commercialisation of counter-cultural or oppositional sub-genres of music (e.g Gangsta Rap or Punk music)

Venue: Maths Room (Old College)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 2After Round 2After Round 4
Opening GovernmentSWING Katy + David (Swing Teams)Fourth013th (2 points, 145 speaks)21st (2 points, 283 speaks)25th (3 points, 564 speaks)
Opening OppositionBHAM James (University of Birmingham)First311th (2 points, 151 speaks)6th (5 points, 305 speaks)6th (8 points, 609 speaks)
Closing GovernmentCOMP University of Pyongyang A (Composite Teams)Second29th (2 points, 156 speaks)9th (4 points, 306 speaks)21st (4 points, 597 speaks)
Closing OppositionLIV Yellow Submateam (University of Liverpool)Third116th (1 points, 150 speaks)19th (2 points, 298 speaks)10th (7 points, 602 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Aberystwyth PeopleSWING Katy + David67
Hannah ClareLIV Yellow Submateam73
Ioan NascuCOMP University of Pyongyang A76
Jack StanleyLIV Yellow Submateam75
KatySWING Katy + David71
Owen YeoCOMP University of Pyongyang A74
Tom RedgraveBHAM James76
Tommy CaveBHAM James78

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairDom CottrellUnaffiliated (N/A)
PanelistSam ShepherdSwansea University (SWAN)
PanelistMichael KearyUnaffiliated (N/A)
PanelistHayley MylesUnaffiliated (N/A)

Round 3

Motion: Upon the creation of strong AI, THW hardwire AI units with an unassailable and unalterable moral code

Venue: Modern Languages Room (Old College)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 3After Round 3After Round 4
Opening GovernmentCOMP University of Pyongyang A (Composite Teams)Fourth09th (4 points, 306 speaks)15th (4 points, 457 speaks)21st (4 points, 597 speaks)
Opening OppositionLIV FC (University of Liverpool)Third18th (4 points, 307 speaks)10th (5 points, 462 speaks)11th (6 points, 612 speaks)
Closing GovernmentBRISTOL Badger Tank (Bristol University)Second25th (5 points, 317 speaks)4th (7 points, 477 speaks)4th (8 points, 637 speaks)
Closing OppositionWARWICK Toby Almy is not edgy (University of Warwick)First33rd (5 points, 323 speaks)2nd (8 points, 486 speaks)2nd (10 points, 649 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Alistair CraigLIV FC76
Ben AndrewBRISTOL Badger Tank81
Edward ManceyWARWICK Toby Almy is not edgy81
Elle FlemingLIV FC79
Frank Grimsey-JonesBRISTOL Badger Tank79
Ioan NascuCOMP University of Pyongyang A75
Owen YeoCOMP University of Pyongyang A76
Tito SarrionandiaWARWICK Toby Almy is not edgy82

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairJames CloughUnaffiliated (N/A)
PanelistEd MiddletonUnaffiliated (N/A)
PanelistGemma TuckwoodSwansea University (SWAN)
PanelistLouise DoughtyUnaffiliated (N/A)

Round 4

Motion: In all western liberal democracies, This House Would ban gay conversion therapy

Venue: Maths Room (Old College)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 4After Round 4After Round 4
Opening GovernmentSWAN Seriously though, Free Justin Bieber (Swansea University)Second219th (3 points, 439 speaks)17th (5 points, 585 speaks)17th (5 points, 585 speaks)
Opening OppositionCARD On time, honest (Cardiff University)Third121st (3 points, 427 speaks)22nd (4 points, 570 speaks)22nd (4 points, 570 speaks)
Closing GovernmentCOMP Warcards (Composite Teams)First318th (3 points, 447 speaks)14th (6 points, 598 speaks)14th (6 points, 598 speaks)
Closing OppositionCOMP University of Pyongyang A (Composite Teams)Fourth015th (4 points, 457 speaks)21st (4 points, 597 speaks)21st (4 points, 597 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Abi PalmerCOMP Warcards75
Egle GradeckaiteCARD On time, honest72
Ioan NascuCOMP University of Pyongyang A70
Owen YeoCOMP University of Pyongyang A70
Rachel WarrenCOMP Warcards76
Rhydian MorrisSWAN Seriously though, Free Justin Bieber73
Richard von GladwellSWAN Seriously though, Free Justin Bieber73
Sally MannanCARD On time, honest71

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairCaitlin JonesBristol University (BRISTOL)
PanelistLamia LoukilUniversity of Warwick (WARWICK)
PanelistLouise DoughtyUnaffiliated (N/A)
PanelistTom TrevsUnaffiliated (N/A)