Team Overview for team TCD PHIL A (TCD Phil)

Speakers: Eoin O'Gorman and Chris Costigan

Round 1

Motion: THW give two votes to women in political elections

Venue: V301 (SOAS)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 1After Round 1After Round 5
Opening GovernmentSHEFF Goldilocks and the one bear (Sheffield)Second21st (0 points, 0 speaks)20th (2 points, 160 speaks)15th (10 points, 770 speaks)
Opening OppositionOXFORD C (Oxford Union)First31st (0 points, 0 speaks)1st (3 points, 164 speaks)1st (14 points, 838 speaks)
Closing GovernmentTCD PHIL A (TCD Phil)Third11st (0 points, 0 speaks)39th (1 points, 159 speaks)10th (10 points, 798 speaks)
Closing OppositionUCL King (University College London)Fourth01st (0 points, 0 speaks)58th (0 points, 153 speaks)43rd (7 points, 740 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Calum YoungSHEFF Goldilocks and the one bear81
Chris CostiganTCD PHIL A78
Eoin O'GormanTCD PHIL A81
Jamie JacksonOXFORD C83
Jan-Alexander GreiweUCL King76
Jess PearceSHEFF Goldilocks and the one bear79
Joonsang LeeUCL King77
Raffy MarshallOXFORD C81

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairJoe DyerUnaffiliated (-)
PanelistRyan FiskeHull (HULL)
PanelistMahesh KaruLincolns Inn (LINCOLNS INN)
PanelistCameron DorlasUCD L+H (UCD L+H)

Round 2

Motion: This house believes that law enforcement organisations should never provide incentives to gang members to inform on their superiors (e.g. plea bargains or monetary rewards)

Venue: V326 (SOAS)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 2After Round 2After Round 5
Opening GovernmentUCL Vaughan (University College London)Fourth051st (1 points, 145 speaks)65th (1 points, 295 speaks)52nd (6 points, 746 speaks)
Opening OppositionLINCOLNS INN A (Lincolns Inn)Second251st (1 points, 145 speaks)44th (3 points, 298 speaks)63rd (5 points, 722 speaks)
Closing GovernmentNOTT Lightning (Nottingham)Third148th (1 points, 146 speaks)51st (2 points, 298 speaks)68th (4 points, 731 speaks)
Closing OppositionTCD PHIL A (TCD Phil)First339th (1 points, 159 speaks)15th (4 points, 319 speaks)10th (10 points, 798 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Adam KayaniNOTT Lightning77
Anirudh MandagereLINCOLNS INN A77
Calypso BlajLINCOLNS INN A76
Chris CostiganTCD PHIL A80
Ciara BerryNOTT Lightning75
Eoin O'GormanTCD PHIL A80
Margareta ChlubnovaUCL Vaughan75
Raluca VacaruUCL Vaughan75

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairMuhammad Asadullah KhanCambridge (CAM)
PanelistYucheng LuLSE (LSE)
PanelistClaire DewshiKing's College London (KCL)

Round 3

Motion: This house regrets the decline in oil prices over the last 18 months

Venue: V329 (SOAS)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 3After Round 3After Round 5
Opening GovernmentBERLIN A (Berlin)Second226th (4 points, 305 speaks)19th (6 points, 465 speaks)29th (8 points, 764 speaks)
Opening OppositionTCD PHIL A (TCD Phil)First315th (4 points, 319 speaks)6th (7 points, 484 speaks)10th (10 points, 798 speaks)
Closing GovernmentUCD L+H D (UCD L+H)Fourth040th (3 points, 298 speaks)53rd (3 points, 449 speaks)56th (6 points, 733 speaks)
Closing OppositionMDU A (Manchester)Third119th (4 points, 315 speaks)25th (5 points, 471 speaks)28th (8 points, 765 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Chris CostiganTCD PHIL A82
Dean FoleyMDU A78
Eoin O'GormanTCD PHIL A83
Florian GBERLIN A80
Joshua Kieran-GlennonUCD L+H D75
Laura HoganUCD L+H D76
Laura SmithMDU A78
Lillian SefferBERLIN A80

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairHarish NatarajanCambridge (CAM)
PanelistBenjamin HiltonImperial College London (IMPERIAL)
PanelistYucheng LuLSE (LSE)
PanelistSophie Scharlin-PetteeOxford Union (OXFORD)

Round 4

Motion: This house believes that Donald Trump's presidential campaign is good for America

Venue: V326 (SOAS)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 4After Round 4After Round 5
Opening GovernmentTCD PHIL A (TCD Phil)Fourth06th (7 points, 484 speaks)21st (7 points, 640 speaks)10th (10 points, 798 speaks)
Opening OppositionLSE SY (LSE)Third113th (7 points, 468 speaks)15th (8 points, 626 speaks)14th (10 points, 782 speaks)
Closing GovernmentSCIENCES PO MM (Sciences Po Paris)Second214th (7 points, 457 speaks)10th (9 points, 617 speaks)17th (10 points, 770 speaks)
Closing OppositionJESUS HT (Jesus College)First320th (6 points, 465 speaks)7th (9 points, 629 speaks)8th (11 points, 777 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Anika MillerSCIENCES PO MM79
Chris CostiganTCD PHIL A78
Eoin O'GormanTCD PHIL A78
Joe MayesSCIENCES PO MM81
Jure HederihJESUS HT81
Nicholas TanJESUS HT83
Sarah TayLSE SY78
Sean Ying YingLSE SY80

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairHelena IvanovUnaffiliated (-)
PanelistMuhammad Asadullah KhanCambridge (CAM)
PanelistHelen LawlessUnaffiliated (-)

Round 5

Motion: This house would allow countries to pay other countries to settle refugees who reach their borders

Venue: V224 (SOAS)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 5After Round 5After Round 5
Opening GovernmentSHEFF Subconscious Judging Biases (Sheffield)Second230th (7 points, 593 speaks)26th (9 points, 744 speaks)26th (9 points, 744 speaks)
Opening OppositionUCL Vaughan (University College London)Fourth037th (6 points, 604 speaks)52nd (6 points, 746 speaks)52nd (6 points, 746 speaks)
Closing GovernmentOXFORD TM (Oxford Union)Third128th (7 points, 612 speaks)32nd (8 points, 758 speaks)32nd (8 points, 758 speaks)
Closing OppositionTCD PHIL A (TCD Phil)First321st (7 points, 640 speaks)10th (10 points, 798 speaks)10th (10 points, 798 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Chris CostiganTCD PHIL A78
Eoin O'GormanTCD PHIL A80
Lucía ArceSHEFF Subconscious Judging Biases76
Magdalena WąwoźnaSHEFF Subconscious Judging Biases75
Margareta ChlubnovaUCL Vaughan71
Meera SachdevaOXFORD TM72
Raluca VacaruUCL Vaughan71
Tim SharpeOXFORD TM74

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairCraig McDonaldCardiff University (CARD)
PanelistRobert GaddInner Temple (INNER)
PanelistMackenzie TseLancaster University (LANC)