Team Overview for team TCD PHIL B (TCD Phil)

Speakers: Stepan Lavoruk and Conan Quinn

Round 1

Motion: THW give two votes to women in political elections

Venue: V211 (SOAS)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 1After Round 1After Round 5
Opening GovernmentLSE OS (LSE)Fourth01st (0 points, 0 speaks)64th (0 points, 145 speaks)42nd (7 points, 748 speaks)
Opening OppositionSCIENCES PO MM (Sciences Po Paris)Second21st (0 points, 0 speaks)23rd (2 points, 156 speaks)17th (10 points, 770 speaks)
Closing GovernmentTCD PHIL B (TCD Phil)First31st (0 points, 0 speaks)6th (3 points, 159 speaks)25th (9 points, 759 speaks)
Closing OppositionCAM Hajj (Cambridge)Third11st (0 points, 0 speaks)41st (1 points, 154 speaks)22nd (9 points, 772 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Anika MillerSCIENCES PO MM77
Conan QuinnTCD PHIL B79
Joe MayesSCIENCES PO MM79
Lydia DayCAM Hajj77
Matt HazellCAM Hajj77
Olisa MLSE OS73
Stepan LavorukTCD PHIL B80
Suah Jian LianLSE OS72

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairTommy CaveUniversity of Birmingham (BIRMINGHAM)
PanelistBenjamin HiltonImperial College London (IMPERIAL)
PanelistValerie TierneyUCD L+H (UCD L+H)

Round 2

Motion: This house believes that law enforcement organisations should never provide incentives to gang members to inform on their superiors (e.g. plea bargains or monetary rewards)

Venue: V224 (SOAS)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 2After Round 2After Round 5
Opening GovernmentUCD L+H C (UCD L+H)Third110th (3 points, 155 speaks)25th (4 points, 306 speaks)31st (8 points, 762 speaks)
Opening OppositionTCD PHIL B (TCD Phil)Second26th (3 points, 159 speaks)9th (5 points, 316 speaks)25th (9 points, 759 speaks)
Closing GovernmentUCL Clapton (University College London)First312th (3 points, 154 speaks)4th (6 points, 320 speaks)7th (11 points, 803 speaks)
Closing OppositionUCD L+H D (UCD L+H)Fourth016th (3 points, 152 speaks)40th (3 points, 298 speaks)56th (6 points, 733 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Aidan PatrickUCL Clapton84
Carl WhelanUCD L+H C77
Conan QuinnTCD PHIL B79
Joshua Kieran-GlennonUCD L+H D73
Juliette BarnesUCD L+H C74
Laura HoganUCD L+H D73
Scott RalstonUCL Clapton82
Stepan LavorukTCD PHIL B78

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairJoe DyerUnaffiliated (-)
PanelistBenjamin HiltonImperial College London (IMPERIAL)
PanelistMackenzie TseLancaster University (LANC)

Round 3

Motion: This house regrets the decline in oil prices over the last 18 months

Venue: V216 (SOAS)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 3After Round 3After Round 5
Opening GovernmentTCD PHIL B (TCD Phil)Third19th (5 points, 316 speaks)21st (6 points, 462 speaks)25th (9 points, 759 speaks)
Opening OppositionIMPERIAL Selling Out to the Man (Imperial College London)First37th (5 points, 321 speaks)4th (8 points, 482 speaks)19th (9 points, 795 speaks)
Closing GovernmentUTRECHT A (Utrecht University)Fourth013th (5 points, 308 speaks)33rd (5 points, 453 speaks)39th (7 points, 755 speaks)
Closing OppositionSCIENCES PO MM (Sciences Po Paris)Second213th (5 points, 308 speaks)14th (7 points, 457 speaks)17th (10 points, 770 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Anika MillerSCIENCES PO MM73
Bruce WeaverIMPERIAL Selling Out to the Man80
Charlie PanhuyzenUTRECHT A73
Conan QuinnTCD PHIL B71
Elmar SchmittUTRECHT A72
Joe MayesSCIENCES PO MM76
Nick ZervoudisIMPERIAL Selling Out to the Man81
Stepan LavorukTCD PHIL B75

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairHelena IvanovUnaffiliated (-)
PanelistMatthew CreeseSheffield (SHEFF)
PanelistAlina BucsaBucharest School of Political Science (BSPS)
PanelistValerie TierneyUCD L+H (UCD L+H)

Round 4

Motion: This house believes that Donald Trump's presidential campaign is good for America

Venue: V327 (SOAS)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 4After Round 4After Round 5
Opening GovernmentMDU A (Manchester)Fourth025th (5 points, 471 speaks)43rd (5 points, 612 speaks)28th (8 points, 765 speaks)
Opening OppositionVIENNA B (Debattierklub Wien)Second222nd (6 points, 451 speaks)20th (8 points, 599 speaks)18th (10 points, 757 speaks)
Closing GovernmentUCD L+H C (UCD L+H)Third118th (6 points, 466 speaks)29th (7 points, 610 speaks)31st (8 points, 762 speaks)
Closing OppositionTCD PHIL B (TCD Phil)First321st (6 points, 462 speaks)11th (9 points, 613 speaks)25th (9 points, 759 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Carl WhelanUCD L+H C73
Conan QuinnTCD PHIL B75
Dean FoleyMDU A70
Juliette BarnesUCD L+H C71
Laura SmithMDU A71
Mark EtzelVIENNA B75
Miriana MunteanVIENNA B73
Stepan LavorukTCD PHIL B76

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairOlivia Sundberg DiezUnaffiliated (-)
PanelistMatthew CreeseSheffield (SHEFF)
PanelistDavid McLarenStrathclyde (STRATH)
PanelistRudraniUniversity College London (UCL)

Round 5

Motion: This house would allow countries to pay other countries to settle refugees who reach their borders

Venue: V222 (SOAS)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 5After Round 5After Round 5
Opening GovernmentBPP A (BPP)First36th (9 points, 632 speaks)4th (12 points, 782 speaks)4th (12 points, 782 speaks)
Opening OppositionSHEFF Goldilocks and the one bear (Sheffield)Third19th (9 points, 623 speaks)15th (10 points, 770 speaks)15th (10 points, 770 speaks)
Closing GovernmentJESUS HT (Jesus College)Second27th (9 points, 629 speaks)8th (11 points, 777 speaks)8th (11 points, 777 speaks)
Closing OppositionTCD PHIL B (TCD Phil)Fourth011th (9 points, 613 speaks)25th (9 points, 759 speaks)25th (9 points, 759 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Calum YoungSHEFF Goldilocks and the one bear74
Conan QuinnTCD PHIL B73
Jess PearceSHEFF Goldilocks and the one bear73
Jure HederihJESUS HT74
Nathan ChalkBPP A74
Nicholas TanJESUS HT74
Nissim MassaranoBPP A76
Stepan LavorukTCD PHIL B73

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairHelena IvanovUnaffiliated (-)
PanelistValerie TierneyUCD L+H (UCD L+H)
PanelistDara KeemanUCD L+H (UCD L+H)