Team Overview for team CARD The Pilsner Lovers (Cardiff University)

Speakers: Chiara Alessandri and Usman Mahmood Bukhari

Round 1

Motion: THBT Universities and Student Unions should adopt and aggressively enforce no platform policies

Venue: Seminar Room 1 (Fulton House)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 1After Round 1After Round 4
Opening GovernmentABER Pint of Clash (Aberystwyth University)Third11st (0 points, 0 speaks)11th (1 points, 144 speaks)10th (6 points, 579 speaks)
Opening OppositionPLYM Plymouth Avengers (Plymouth University)First31st (0 points, 0 speaks)1st (3 points, 154 speaks)8th (6 points, 603 speaks)
Closing GovernmentCARD The Pilsner Lovers (Cardiff University)Fourth01st (0 points, 0 speaks)13th (0 points, 143 speaks)4th (8 points, 593 speaks)
Closing OppositionABER D (Aberystwyth University)Second21st (0 points, 0 speaks)8th (2 points, 145 speaks)11th (5 points, 568 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Ayotunde SokalePLYM Plymouth Avengers78
Ben SimmsABER Pint of Clash72
Chiara AlessandriCARD The Pilsner Lovers68
David AyresABER D71
Rachel SweeneyPLYM Plymouth Avengers76
Tim EldonABER D74
Usman Mahmood BukhariCARD The Pilsner Lovers75
Yamina AlouiABER Pint of Clash72

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairJoseph LewisUnaffiliated (-)
PanelistLucy GrimesBangor University (BANG)
PanelistJon OfficerBangor University (BANG)
PanelistKonstantinos KrespisUnaffiliated (-)

Round 2

Motion: THBT religious schools should be forced to appoint atheist staff members to teach atheism as a valid alternative to religious belief

Venue: Seminar Room 5 (Fulton House)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 2After Round 2After Round 4
Opening GovernmentBANG Massdebating (Bangor University)Second213th (0 points, 143 speaks)12th (2 points, 288 speaks)13th (4 points, 436 speaks)
Opening OppositionCARD The Pilsner Lovers (Cardiff University)First313th (0 points, 143 speaks)9th (3 points, 290 speaks)4th (8 points, 593 speaks)
Closing GovernmentBANG Adam and Yaseen (Bangor University)Third116th (0 points, 136 speaks)15th (1 points, 278 speaks)16th (2 points, 495 speaks)
Closing OppositionPLYM Reigning Champions (Plymouth University)Fourth015th (0 points, 140 speaks)16th (0 points, 279 speaks)15th (2 points, 562 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Adam PalmerBANG Adam and Yaseen71
Alexander LeaPLYM Reigning Champions70
Carl MonaghanBANG Massdebating72
Chiara AlessandriCARD The Pilsner Lovers74
John HanleyBANG Massdebating73
Martin WeaverPLYM Reigning Champions69
Usman Mahmood BukhariCARD The Pilsner Lovers73
Yaseen SheikhBANG Adam and Yaseen71

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairAndrew RoseUnaffiliated (-)
PanelistTom WolfeAberystwyth University (ABER)
PanelistHarri Ellington-LewisUnaffiliated (-)

Round 3

Motion: As a working class voter in a Labour/Conservative marginal constituency, THW vote Conservative

Venue: Seminar Room 5 (Fulton House)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 3After Round 3After Round 4
Opening GovernmentABER D (Aberystwyth University)Third16th (4 points, 279 speaks)8th (5 points, 423 speaks)11th (5 points, 568 speaks)
Opening OppositionBANG Taylor-Petts-Lewis (Bangor University)Fourth010th (3 points, 279 speaks)13th (3 points, 422 speaks)12th (4 points, 558 speaks)
Closing GovernmentCARD Alex Salmond for Prime Minister (Cardiff University)Second24th (4 points, 300 speaks)4th (6 points, 452 speaks)6th (7 points, 600 speaks)
Closing OppositionCARD The Pilsner Lovers (Cardiff University)First39th (3 points, 290 speaks)6th (6 points, 443 speaks)4th (8 points, 593 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Chiara AlessandriCARD The Pilsner Lovers80
David AyresABER D72
Ed MasonCARD Alex Salmond for Prime Minister77
Jack Petts-LewisBANG Taylor-Petts-Lewis72
Josh GreenCARD Alex Salmond for Prime Minister75
Natalia TaylorBANG Taylor-Petts-Lewis71
Tim EldonABER D72
Usman Mahmood BukhariCARD The Pilsner Lovers73

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairNissim MassaranoUnaffiliated (-)
PanelistJoseph LewisUnaffiliated (-)
PanelistJon OfficerBangor University (BANG)
PanelistHarri Ellington-LewisUnaffiliated (-)

Round 4

Motion: THBT the USA should legalise the manufacture and sale of all drugs

Venue: Dining Room C (Fulton House)

Teams:

RoleTeamRankingPointsBefore Round 4After Round 4After Round 4
Opening GovernmentABER Sleepyheads (Aberystwyth University)First37th (5 points, 426 speaks)5th (8 points, 577 speaks)5th (8 points, 577 speaks)
Opening OppositionCARD The Pilsner Lovers (Cardiff University)Second26th (6 points, 443 speaks)4th (8 points, 593 speaks)4th (8 points, 593 speaks)
Closing GovernmentABER D (Aberystwyth University)Fourth08th (5 points, 423 speaks)11th (5 points, 568 speaks)11th (5 points, 568 speaks)
Closing OppositionCARD Alex Salmond for Prime Minister (Cardiff University)Third14th (6 points, 452 speaks)6th (7 points, 600 speaks)6th (7 points, 600 speaks)

Speakers:

NameTeamPoints
Chiara AlessandriCARD The Pilsner Lovers75
David AyresABER D72
Ed MasonCARD Alex Salmond for Prime Minister75
Josh GreenCARD Alex Salmond for Prime Minister73
Miriam SugdenABER Sleepyheads76
Tim EldonABER D73
Usman Mahmood BukhariCARD The Pilsner Lovers75
Will BlanchardABER Sleepyheads75

Adjudicators:

RoleNameUniversity
ChairAndrew RoseUnaffiliated (-)
PanelistJon OfficerBangor University (BANG)
PanelistTom WolfeAberystwyth University (ABER)
PanelistMarcus LeaUnaffiliated (-)